Plausible vs Umami: Which Should You Use?

Plausible docs screenshot of the top-graph visitor metrics on the simple dashboard — Plausible docs top-graph.png. Source · License: AGPL-3.0.

forkalt identification graphic for Umami with MIT license and 2026-10-21 star snapshot — forkalt identification graphic (2026-10-21). Source · License: forkalt original.

Verdict. Choose Plausible if you want the AGPL cookie-free Elixir dashboard (29,577 stars, v3.2.1). Choose Umami if you want MIT and a TypeScript tree (39,493 stars, v3.4.0). We have no sourced accuracy or performance test against each other or GA4.

Compare Plausible Analytics and Umami.

Dimension	Plausible Analytics	Umami	Source
License	AGPL-3.0 (LICENSE.md, 2026-10-21)	MIT (LICENSE, 2026-10-21)	Official LICENSE files
Price (software)	free self-host; cloud sold separately	free self-host; cloud sold separately	READMEs
Current release (this check)	v3.2.1 (2026-05-15)	v3.4.0 (2026-09-17)	GitHub Releases
Community snapshot (2026-10-21)	29,577 stars / 1,913 forks; last push 2026-10-20	39,493 stars / 8,357 forks; last push 2026-10-20	GitHub API
Stack	Elixir / Phoenix	TypeScript	GitHub language fields
Cookies (project claim)	cookie-free (README / description)	no cookies (description)	GitHub README / description; not independently audited
Quality vs GA4	Not independently tested	Not independently tested	n/a

When to choose which

AGPL cookie-free dashboard: Plausible — Copied license and README labels. We did not audit the script.
MIT TypeScript self-host: Umami — Copied license and language. We did not run a Docker bake-off.
Full PHP analytics suite: Matomo — Different stack. See the Google Analytics hub (GPL-3.0, 5.14.1).

Read the entity pages for the full sourced tables: Plausible and Umami. Both are listed on Google Analytics alternatives. Versus the commercial product: Plausible vs Google Analytics. Related full-stack row: Matomo.

Key differences

Plausible is AGPL-3.0 and Elixir. Umami is MIT and TypeScript. Both READMEs describe cookie-free / no-cookie privacy-first dashboards — those are project claims, not a forkalt script audit. Star counts are not quality.

See also Zapier alternatives if the job is automation rather than analytics, and Dev & Coding.

FAQ

Is Umami better than Plausible?

We have no sourced benchmark that says so. The sourced differences are license and stack.

Can I use both?

Yes, on different sites. Read AGPL-3.0 if you will offer Plausible as a service. Not legal advice.

What about Matomo?

Matomo is the GPL-3.0 PHP/MySQL option on Google Analytics alternatives (21,964 stars, 5.14.1).

Sources & verification

Last verified 2026-10-21 · Last updated 2026-10-21· Edited by forkalt editors · Editorial policy

License notes are not legal advice. Read the original LICENSE. Trademark & disclaimer.